Coconut Key Lime Pie Cup

By Michelle Savage

Through my battle with weight and health issues, it took some time to learn how to satisfy my sweet tooth with nutritious food. Through kitchen blunders and triumphs, the Coconut Key Lime Pie Cup was created.

This sweet treat has been a hit with my family and friends – well, and myself!

Coconut Key Lime Pie Cup


1 cup coconut cream

1/8 cup key lime, juiced – approx. 3 key limes 

1 tsp. alcohol-free vanilla extract

2 tbsp. plus 1 teaspoon agave

½ cup pecans

7 dates, pitted and diced

1 tsp. cacao powder

Garnish with 1 tsp. lime zest (optional)


  1. For the crust, place pecans in a small food processor; pulsate nuts until small and crumbly.
  2. Toss in diced dates; pulsate until the mixture becomes gooey.
  3. Sprinkle in the cacao powder and 1 tsp. agave; pulsate until the mixture is dark, chocolatey and fluffy. Note: Don’t over process; that can cause the crust to become too buttery. 
  4. Divide the mixture and gently press into the bottom of two small glasses or two 4-ounce Mason jars; cover and refrigerate while making the key lime filling.
  5. For the pie filling, blend coconut cream, lime juice, vanilla, and 2 tbsp. agave in a large mixing bowl with an “electric mixer” until there are light and fluffy peeks of cream.
  6. Remove the Mason jars from the refrigerator and gently spoon and divide the coconut key lime pie filling over the crust
  7. Top with lime zest and refrigerate for at least 2 hours
  8. Remove from the fridge, get two little spoons, and share with your favorite person!
  9. Garnish with a sprinkle of coconut sugar or macaroon coconut flakes, if desired.
  10. Enjoy!


Michelle Savage is an Integrative Nutrition Health Coach with a passion for teaching middle-aged individuals in her community who struggle with weight problems how to take control over their lives again. By educating them on food and freedom, she shows them the path back to confidence. Her recent accomplishments include: publishing her first book, The Green Aisle’s Healthy Smoothies & Slushies: More than 75 Healthy Recipes to Help You Lose Weight and Get Fit, appearing on Good Morning Sacramento, a feature article in the Manteca Bulletin, and formal congratulations from House Representative Jeff Denham for her book and efforts to make the Valley a healthier region. Visit her website Green Aisle Wellness to learn more!

4 thoughts on “Coconut Key Lime Pie Cup

  1. I love anything with coconut and these are pretty good and delicious ingredients, however according to MyFitnessPal it comes to 750 calories/serving. I realize not all calories are created equal, but we do still need to be aware of them and that is just way too calorie-dense for one snack in my book.

Leave a Reply